At the end of the interview, we’re outside, Ryan
bonding about love of the environment, taking
out a cigarette and smoking, and I notice how he
doesn’t notice the odd juxtaposition, pointing it
out, which I’ve done with him for the last couple
hours, how protests, so often, are filled with contra-
dictions, complexities, the way I’ve been struggling
with how many arrests by ICE were done by Obama’s
administration and how those silent arrests aren’t
getting any attention now, as if only the current
administration has done mass arrests, but where
it seems not to make a difference, which party
is partying at the White House, and this is some-
thing we bond on, Ryan, “the media guy” for
this protest, the first person I talked to quickly
shuffling things to him, where I was worried
about a “media guy,” telling him that up front,
that the worry is he’d give me cliched quotes,
but he doesn’t, telling me that it really doesn’t
make a difference if Dems or Reps are in control,
that those two parties do the same repetition,
damning the damned further, and the thing Ryan
wants broken is the blockade of Cuba, a member
of AWAN—not the Muslim agrarian tribe Awan,
but the Anti-War Action Network, which, weirdly,
puts the emphasis on war, not peace, and war
language seems to pop up throughout the event,
one of the eight people on the live webinar using
the language of the U.S. being the “enemy” and
Israel being the “enemy,” a moment that causes
discomfort in me, but the revelation that this
isn’t a progressive meeting, a liberal protest,
that it’s something else, online criticisms that
AWAN aligns with anti-U.S. “radical”/“fringe”
elements, and it’s perhaps this alignment that
creates such a small selection of attendees, only
three that I see, and all three sit as far apart
from each other as possible, so that there’s
no feel of unity, no networking, no mingling
after, or during, or before. It’s disconnection,
but it feels disconnection is central to the goals,
a disconnect from U.S. “imperialist” stances,
that word popping up nonstop, as does “geno-
cide,” so much so that it starts to lose meaning,
feel slogan-y. This isn’t Indivisible roadside
F- Trump signs seeking horn-beep camaraderie.
This is more comrades, Soviet-style, embracing
Socialism, strongly, a key part of the message
so that the webinar slide show projected onto
a white cement wall with lunar landing craters
so much so that I can’t make out their Zoomed
names under their faces, only able to make out
a (perhaps) Meredith (?); whereas, Indivisible types
are pure binary—Democrats, good; Republicans,
evil—where they don’t really let you know who
they love, who we should vote for, but, instead,
who we should despise, who we should most
definitely not vote for, a craving I always have
at protests where I want to ask, “OK, so who
do you like?” and not just to ask that, but so
I can then research, check them out, a thing
that happened with me with Obama, where
it wasn’t a ‘hate McCain’ vibe, but, rather,
the much more powerful ‘love Obama’ vibe,
which is how Obama won in a landslide, at
least electorally, but what I realize watching
the webinar is this is distinctly not a Dem or
Rep crowd, but, rather, an “anti-American
imperialism” crowd, where the webinarers
definitely despise Trump but especially, of
all things, Marco Rubio, which feels a bit
like aiming your distaste at Iago instead of
Jafar in Aladdin. Another opposite to omni-
present Indivisible is the age. These webinar
folks are young, really young, not sexagenarians
doing ol’ fashioned hold-up-a-sign-at-roadsides,
but, instead, talking through tech, no touch,
no true interaction, but committed, and their
commitment is to Cuba, a country they rave
about, have multiple slides about “Socialist
Achievement” like Cuba’s “Literary Campaign”
and “Rights to Medical Care” and what’s claimed
as impressive anti-racism, but, a strange thing,
when I go to look up global rankings for such
things as health care and literacy, Cuba’s not
on any of the lists, almost like it doesn’t even
exist, but what I find is human rights violations
in terms of mass repression of dissent, where
the irony of their depictions of Cuba as Heaven
and America as Hell miss that the room is filled
with dissidents and I see myself as a journalist,
and all of us, all the dissident and a free-speech
journalist would be arrested in Cuba, denying
us of that medical care, and the incarceration
system in Cuba has a similar reputation of being
U.S.-ish racist. I bring this up to Ryan post-webinar,
in a long monologue, hitting on all these points.
He wants to end the interview. I encourage him
to not quit, but to use logic instead. The reality
is Ryan is well-spoken. He’s passionate, a thing
I like about going to these various protests. If
you’re taking all this time from your life in
dedication to whatever—encouraging voting,
hating the President, wanting to end a blockade
against Cuba, whatever—you tend to have
a heartbeat, tend to bring something to the table,
and the thing I find, often, is, simply, intelligence.
Ryan knows history, tells me, “I’ll blow you away”
with what he’s about to say and what he’s about
to say is he supports the U.S. intervention in
World War II, that the Nazis did need to be
combatted. The worries about webinar members
flirting with antisemitism earlier seem to be
addressed in this point, at least for Ryan. And,
what I find, is that these dissidents all have
different views. More different than dissident,
a hodgepodge of beliefs, interests, focuses.
They speak of their trip to Cuba, on “buses,”
where they were chauffeured to the various
highlights of the country. I tell Ryan I worry
about how that’s done with prisons, that you
show volunteers one part of the prison to do
positive publicity, but you hide other portions
of the prison that would give a bad impression.
I wonder if they’re being manipulated. Online,
it mentioned Cuba and Palestine in their promotional
materials for this event, but Palestine is a side note.
The focus is Cuba, especially the “genocide” of
the blockades, blockades that have been maintained
since JFK, so it doesn’t matter who’s in office.
Ryan knows this, and he’s dissatisfied with both
parties. I encourage him to connect, try to make change
with, perhaps, whichever party seems more open,which appears to be the Democrats, mention getting
involved more in politics, and Ryan says living is
political, that everything is a political act. I ask if
he’s an anarchist. “No.” His reply is definitive.
He highlights “children suffering.” I tell him he
doesn’t come across as a radical, as someone who’d
want to do bombings, but, actually, is concerned
about deaths of Cubans, of Cuban children, Cuban
babies, hospitals working in the dark due to outages,
lack of food, lack of pharmaceuticals. Lack. But
how to address it if both political parties in the U.S.
back it? We discuss the one-party system of Cuba,
how that might frighten the U.S. A webinar speaker
says the U.S. is afraid of seeing a country that enacts
true anti-racist policies, and my worry is that there’s
this exaggeration of Cuba = positive, and U.S. = bad.
Ryan dismisses Human Rights Watch claims against
Cuba, questioning if they’re in the pocket of the U.S.
I hit hard on the free speech we’re doing right now,
the things they’re saying on the webinar that they
can say so openly that couldn’t be said in Cuba.
But, then, not provoked by Ryan, but, on my own,
I look up other pro-Cuba orgs and find that there’s
been continuous monitoring of those individuals,
investigations, that the free speech of the U.S. might
actually be not so free. I wonder if even this event
is being overseen, but then realize it’s just three
attendees. It’s too small. But what if it was larger?
Then would it become a shutting down of that same
free speech that would be done in Cuba? I noticed
the protests online have reduced for upcoming events
post-midterm elections. Because liberals got what
they wanted. So they’re happy. What’s to protest
when the pendulum is swinging so strongly in your
direction? But I think of just Michigan for the last
four Presidential elections, how every single election
that state votes a different way. How Democrats come
in and let them down, then Republican come in and
let them down, so they go back to Dems who let them
down again, and repeat. For this group in this room,
there’s nothing they can do. Economic restrictions of
Cuba have been going on since 1960. Kennedy, Johnson,
Nixon, Ford, Carter, Reagan, Bush, Clinton, Bush II,
Obama, Trump. It doesn’t matter. And so this is why
the U.S. is the “enemy.” When neither party is giving
you what you want, you give up on both. I talk to Ryan,
tell him how smart he is, him letting me know he has no
college degree. I could see him crushing courses in
International Relations, Poli Sci, History. But he seems
proud of being out of the system. I ask what he wants
to do. He clarifies—for Cuba? For him? For him.
He says he’d like to get involved with “buildings.”
I don’t get into details of real estate or architecture.
But it’s fitting. ‘Building’ is what he does. He’s
starting small. The room is filled with chairs, filled
with all these empty chairs, a room that feels better
fit for garage bands than a coffee shop. Humble
beginnings. He’s building. I wonder if it’d be
easier to build if the focus was more positive,
more Peace than Anti-War. I let him go, cigarette
in hand, his final words of “Listen, the fight for
ending the blockade is also a fight for the people
of the United States.” Adds “the interventionist
policies of the Trump administration hurts our lives.”
Speaks of $4 and $5 gas. “It’s time we do something.”